642 Comments

This year, I'm listening to every piece by J.S. Bach and reflecting on it here:

https://yearofbach.substack.com/

Here's the intro post, 'A year (of all) of Bach':

https://yearofbach.substack.com/p/a-year-of-all-of-bach-a-2024-project

No premium tier, come along and listen.

Expand full comment

Love the idea behind your project, Evan. Just subscribed!

I also write about classical music, and introduced my subscribers to the final movement of the Mass in B Minor in December:

https://open.substack.com/pub/michaelwriteswords/p/js-bach-dona-nobis-pacem-mass-b-minor?r=6d8h3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment

Thanks Michael - will check out your writing on the Mass!

Expand full comment

On the performance and recording side of Bach, I've been playing his cello suites and violin partitas for 60+ years on my clarinet, and during Covid decided to record. I've posted a few renditions on my Youtube playlist, always trying something a bit new and engineering with the background as film sound designer and engineer. Enjoy! https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLhajxP9SFAloYPBeLjJO1NwTF-SsrDL2a

Expand full comment

Amazing. Can't wait to listen to these!

Expand full comment

This has to be one of those projects where we are greatly relieved to learn that you are doing it so we don't have to. We thank you for your service and commitment to the cause!

Expand full comment

Thanks, Tom. I hope it inspires you to go and check out some deep cuts.

Expand full comment

If you’re near Carmel, CA you can catch their annual Bach Festival in July.

Expand full comment

One of the nicest towns in the USA.

Expand full comment

Love this!

Expand full comment

Great idea and an even better execution 💪 Have you considered sharing Spotify / Apple Music links alongside Youtube? I personally find them very useful in music-based substacks.

Expand full comment

Yeah — this is a good idea but it’s more labor intensive than I’d like. YouTube is easiest as everyone can click on it — searching for classical work on Spotify and Apple Music is a challenge in itself. Apple is trying to rectify it in its new app but that’s only on iOS.

Expand full comment

You are right, and that app also has geographic limitations which is a bummer. Anyways, I wish you great luck in your substack.

Expand full comment

Thanks Omur. If you have any favorite recordings of obscure pieces, please let me know.

Expand full comment

This is great, thank you!

Expand full comment

That's an epic project. Subscribed!

Expand full comment

Thanks, Dan... it's a beast, but I'm enjoying it so far.

Expand full comment

Subscribed and looking forward to reading!

Expand full comment

Thanks Robert - my favorite posts so far are the most recent, on the Goldbergs and Martha Argerich:

https://yearofbach.substack.com/p/february-9-the-goldberg-variations

https://yearofbach.substack.com/p/february-6-piano-works-toccata-bwv

Expand full comment

My husband Peco and I are leading a "Communal Digital Fast" on School of the Unconformed. We are inviting our readers to fast from "the virtual" and feast on "the real" during the upcoming Lenten period (everyone is welcome to join!) We have had a tremendous response and have just posted a piece on practical preparations and a visual guide to "Random Acts of Anachronism". Would love to have you join us (or simply come and gather inspiration)!

https://schooloftheunconformed.substack.com/p/fasting-from-the-virtual-feasting

Expand full comment

The Baha'i fast is coming up as well - maybe I will take some inspiration from this!

Expand full comment

I'm very interested in doing this. Subscribed,

Expand full comment

Great to have you along Robert :)

Expand full comment

too funny! I follow you over there already and recognized your name/substack. Good minds and all that ;)

Expand full comment

gosh, a month sounds a lot but it is an enticing idea...

Expand full comment

Not to make it even more daunting...Lent is actually just over six weeks long :) But, why not join for an amount of time you feel is manageable?

Expand full comment

I’m writing my 62th book, a YA called 48 hours. It will be in Dutch, so hardly anyone here will be able to read it. But luckily I have my own audience over here.

Expand full comment

You might be surprised.

Expand full comment

Please pardon me saying this. It seems an overly grim storyline for a YA novel. Granted, many YA are also grim as is life at times, but still...

Expand full comment

It’s definitely grim. Which means the young adults love it (the first book is a huge hit over here) and some adults thinks it’s a bit too much.

Expand full comment

Wow, you are prolific!

Expand full comment

Thank you! It’s my job and I love it!

Expand full comment

62—WOW—congratulations, Marcel!

Expand full comment

Thank you so much ☺️

Expand full comment

What is it about?

Expand full comment

It’s basically The Hunt and it’s a sequel to my book “24 uur” (24 hours) which is about two guys who chase a girl with a gun for a day for fun.

Expand full comment

Oh. I love White Buffalo Woman's chapter in the Sophia Code. Two men of the Soux see a beautiful woman. One recognizes her as a holy woman. The other sees a lost maiden and wants to have them both rape her. She prays with mercy for the sick man's soul, commanding him to return to Wakan Tanka (God) - he voluntarily gives up his spirit and she turns his body to ash. The other man asks for mercy and is given a message for his people, who receive great Medicine Bundles of Wisdom and Prophecy.

Expand full comment

I am doing book reviews to support indie authors 🤎📚 and later I am narrating my 42nd audiobook for audible. Have a great day all! 🤎✨️

Expand full comment

Audio books are the greatest, especially for those who are visually impaired and rely on them for inspiration, information and entertainment. Well done you!

Expand full comment

Thank you! I am always happy to give promo codes for a free listen to anybody who is visually impaired and indeed, anybody that would leave an honest rating 🤎

Expand full comment

That's great. I visited your Substack to see what kind of books you like and was pleased to be able to hear your speaking voice. You have a lovely accent. I've subscribed and look forward to following your posts, and perhaps taking you up on your offer of a free code in exchange for a review.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much! I am just learning the ropes here so I can use it as a hub for my other platforms. Please feel free to drop me an email at ink.readsalot@gmail.com any time you would like an audiobook as I am alwats happy to share and reviews help us a lot. Have a lovely day and thank you again!

Expand full comment

Thanks for the open mic! One of my goals this year is to release an ambient album here on Substack. I’ll be posting one song a month with a little bit written about each song. I wrote the first one at the end of January. https://open.substack.com/pub/minorfossil/p/cavern?r=19bxnh&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

Expand full comment

I have a similar goal but are a little behind your pace. After several decades as an instrumental performer and composer, I am now working to determine the best way to self publish my work. This means taking a portion of my old brain away from creating content and learning to produce a product. In an effort to keep the number of people involved to a minimum (think “1”). At present I am challenging myself to learn to use a DAW for recording/mixing and to determine the best way of reaching the right audience and delivering the finished product - whether that is a recording or a piece of “sheet music” that can be read and performed by others. I’m curious about you decision to use Substack and how you think it’s working for you.

Expand full comment

That sounds exciting! I love it here on Substack. I started releasing my music in 2020 and would hang out on Twitter and Instagram but that got stressful real quick. It’s been slow going here but the connections are wonderful and are what makes it worth it.

Expand full comment

My husband is the ambient music composer, and I have been telling him he should do exactly this! I'm more of a folk composer. I did manage to release a new song in video format with a bit of writing about it once a month all last year on every full moon. It was a lot of work and I had to learn Canva, but it was also really fun and great to have the deadline looming large outside my window. I do recommend releasing music with a video if possible, more people seem to check them out than audios. Best of luck! Now I'll check out your music...!

Expand full comment

I find I’m learning the technology but trying to be both artist and technician makes me appreciate the great recording engineers I took too much for granted in an earlier life. Even referring to them as technicians is understating just what the right person can do to make something pretty good sound brilliant. In my own development, I think I’m at the point of taking something pretty good and making it sound pretty good, but different - a step up from transforming pretty good into God-awful.

Expand full comment

I hear you, and I admire you working on it. I'm lucky to have an in-house brilliant recording engineer so I haven't had to learn to actually do it myself, though I have picked up some stuff. It's so complex, and there are so many aspects to shaping sound, so many different ways to do it, and endless tools. You are right, it is an art form itself, not just "technical" skills. Because even though all the software tools are now affordable and accessible in a way they did not used to be and anyone can be a sound engineer: you still gotta have the ears to hear what is great (and God-awful)!! So it sounds like you are ahead of the curve there and just need to keep playing and experimenting, trusting your own deep sense of taste. One thing we both have learned over the years is that quality matters in both software and hardware. Research, try to buy the best. He has also learned so much from watching videos and taking courses from top-notch engineers, some of which he had to pay for.

Expand full comment

Oh nice! I like the idea of publishing on the full moon. Yea, I guess video might be a next step for me, but it seems really daunting right now.

Expand full comment

I was super daunted for a long time but I finally just learned. Canva is fun and easy once you get past the initial learning curve, even for a non-technical old gal like me. Visuals with music are just so powerful. Even being the composer, I find the images deepen my relationship with the music. f you get the Pro version, you have access to better images and video. Which may or may not work for your music (which sounds great by the way!). In some videos I use our own live footage, or I get images from Wikimedia too. One song I used all these beautiful pre-Raphaelite paintings I got off of Wikimedia because it's kind of a fairy tale story. Another song/vid is a cover of the folk song Loch Lomond, and I used beautifully filmed nature footage in Scotland, provided by Canva Pro. That video has gone all over the world, has over 50,000 views. I know nothing about promoting on Youtube, no idea how that happened. For ambient music, you could learn to play with a graphics program to make abstract or psychedelic images that unfold during the song, and that might be a super simple way to illustrate your music since there aren't lyrics. Good luck!

Expand full comment

Can you please give an example of the graphic program that you think would be useful in creating videos for my instrumental music

Expand full comment

I use Canva Pro (not the free version). Here is one I just created for a lyric video to go with one of my songs:

https://youtu.be/DCqNOOKrgzo?si=UT4PcIA45PMJ_1AB

Here is another earlier one that somehow got 56,000 views, a cover of Loch Lomond:

https://youtu.be/mQ5FjagydJw?si=6AlTGhT1T6CjMrKp

I got all the footage from Canva for these, which both feature a lot of nature shots. I've also used clips of actors for narrative videos. Here is one of those:

https://youtu.be/HsUuDOivzrI?si=UwojY7iCQ3W2dTFV

Sometimes I use my own footage or photos or sometimes I use Wikimedia, but Canva has gorgeous, professional film clips. I love nature shots and they have many from around the world. I don't know if that would work for you artistically, but they also have abstract images and are beginning to offer AI designed footage if you want abstract images to go with the music.

There is a learning curve and I have far from mastered the possibilities--but I am SO not a technical person OR a young person and I figured it out. There are plenty of videos about how to use Canva. That way of learning doesn't work for me, but might for you. Hope these examples help, best of luck!

Expand full comment

Thanks will definitely check it out more as well as your videos 👍👍once I get a video done I’ll share it on here

Expand full comment

Yeah those nature shots are beautiful.. I’ll also check their AI designed footage for some of my songs that would definitely need some of those abstract images based on the inspiration behind them thanks for sharing all those tips I truly appreciate it

Expand full comment

Hey, I love ambient music and have been dipping my toes into the genre myself! Will definitely subscribe, and feel free to check out my stuff. Let's be in touch :-)

https://linktr.ee/vigilancebrandon

Expand full comment

Hey thank you! Yea ambient is pretty awesome. Your Fogarea Ep was great, I enjoyed listening

Expand full comment

Listening to the track cavern cool ethereal companion while reading a Jules Verne book 😉 I think I read Journey to the center of the earth way back in the day

Expand full comment

Thanks, yea I think it was the first one I read by him a long time ago.

Expand full comment

Sounds cool I have a dozen instrumental tracks that I am at the moment getting it sorted into an album at the moment.. how does one release an album here on substack ?

Expand full comment

I'm just posting one song every month until the album is complete. Then I'll release it out into the world. So until then it's only available here on Substack. It's nothing official.

Expand full comment

Check out my podcast Herizon Music for interviews with two ambient album GRAMMY nominees. Carla Patullo (who won last week!) and Cheryl B. Engelhardt.

Expand full comment

Interesting I’ll definitely give it a listen!

Expand full comment
Feb 12·edited Feb 12

We are building Lissen (https://www.lissen.live/), the interactive music platform combining streaming and artist-to-fan experiences.

Our complementary approach aligns incentives between artists and fans, resulting in a music experience way more engaging, in a more sustainable ecosystem.

These features can only be built upon the unique and open fan-centric music license we created.

Similar to what Substack/Ghost brought to journalism and news in a sense.

The 2022 YT video with Ted and Rick Beato was amazing and is really close to our thesis for where we think the music world should go to.

We are building in public so if you have any question please don't hesitate!

Expand full comment

Ok this is really cool and I hope I'm not getting ahead of myself but it sounds like smaller artists will be able to create a kind of regional fan base who they reward constantly with all kind of goodies (discounted tickets, +1s, merch raffles etc).

Not everyone needs to be on top of the tops but like this you'd have a lot more people going to events to see their local favorites, more smaller and middle sized venues being filled and definitely more bands that are going to make it. You can seriously contribute to growing the overall entertainment industry and that's really awesome!

Expand full comment

Cheers :)

Indeed interactivity will enable us to bridge IRL and online worlds way better.

And a lot of artists won't have to constantly be offering perks, as their music will speak for itself (same thing when you can get Ed Sheeran tickets if you call your local radio station, it doesn't need to happen all the time, except now it's totally controlled by the music makers!)

Expand full comment

so you are moving away from the pro-rata system with your fan-centric approach (similar to user-centric I guess)? Can you share an example of a feature Lissen has but that we can’t have now on Spotify?

Expand full comment

that's what we are doing indeed! Fan-centric is an evolution of the user-centric model to cover some inherent "hacking" weaknesses user-centric has.

As for the feature, it's important to know that in the fan-centric model, what matters is the quality of the attention you get, not the quantity.

Example with a fan with a $10 monthly subscription, a day is worth circa $0.33.

If this fan only streamed my music today, the whole $0.33 is going to the artist, it's a proportion of your attention, and as you just got 100%, it makes sense you get it directly.

Now, with artists knowing quality matters more, they will want interactive feature to be sure they incentivise their fans to get their attention.

One of these feature is called Challenge to help organic discovery: "if you stream my new single today, you enter a raffle to get a free concert ticket"

-> the artists knows s/he will make a part of the $0.33 pot, the fan knows s/he will discover new music and could get a perk. Multiply this by a few 100 fans and you start seeing some real result directly from your audience which creates a healthy cycle (as artists have a lot of perks they don't use right now)

Expand full comment

Will check it out!

Expand full comment

thanks Thea! By leaving your email on our website you will receive our monthly newsletter.

Otherwise you can find me on most socials where I post about our progress :)

Expand full comment

ok so it’s like gamified discovery with incentives on both sides, do you have another feature example?

Expand full comment

yes Challenges are for Discovery, then for example we have Gifts for Community: stay in touch with your fan base and reward them in the way you want (ie. grant an AMA session to your top 10 fans over the last 3 months)

Expand full comment

What do you mean by interactive? Like when I think a music platform, i just think of streaming or downloading music.

Expand full comment

I mean that Lissen will enable you and your artists to interact in a lot of different ways (ie. chat, games, perks...). They can now see you and value you. And it goes both ways!

The aim is to act more like a medium than a platform ;)

Expand full comment

Oh got you, thanks for replying

Expand full comment

That sounds like a great medium to bridge the gap between the artist and fans or potential listeners to the music.. how does it go as far as getting my music set up ?

Expand full comment

You will be able to get your music on Lissen just like on any other DSP, via distributors, labels or even yourself :)

Expand full comment

Sounds like a great idea, but I'm curious who would use this. Is the plan to have "all" music like the major streaming platforms? A twitter account with 200 followers makes me think this isn't mainstream. Or is this for smaller artists to cultivate fans? If so, what's the appeal to fans over platforms like Patreon and Kickstarter (where I love supporting all sorts of music).

Expand full comment

Hi Trevor, regarding the Twitter account size, it's because we just started communicating on socials so mainstream is definitely not there yet :)

The plan is to release the app in the UK in Q2 2024 with as many DIY and indies as possible to show our product market fit -> indeed I think interactivity is what is missing with online music platforms, and it can't be achieved on pro-rata platforms (thus our fan-centric royalty allocation model)

The first audience we are targeting is people like you, already supporting creativity via Patreon/Kickstarter/Bandcamp. The added value we bring is reducing friction (everything under the same platform, no need to create several accounts across siloed apps) and dedicated features for musicians (ie. currently, you can't correlate your music usage from Spotify to Patreon -> on Lissen yes)

Does that make sense?

Expand full comment

My band Timothy Bailey & the Humans is working towards the release of our second album in May. The record is called “New Love Stories.” We’ve decided to eschew all streaming services and are only releasing physical formats via Bandcamp.

There will be a 12” LP and a poster for sale. Both will include digital downloads. We’re primarily trying to build a connection with our unique microculture via our newsletter, “Greater Humanity” here on Substack.

Will this approach work better than the one most bands are using these days? I have no idea. But I do have the middle aged superpower of realistic expectations. Also, I’m collecting data throughout the process in the hope that my findings may be helpful to others in my musical community (Richmond, Virginia) and beyond.

I hope you’ll have a look at our newsletter via my profile. Thanks for this opportunity, Ted.

Expand full comment

Well, I’m a retired television producer living in a little village in the Green Mountains of Vermont. Since I have been up here I have been playing in a local band, whose playlist is made up of originals, old country and rockabilly and about 25% classic golden oldies of the baby boomers. I also play a solo act about once a month at a little roadside restaurant up the highway. And the really dramatic difference I notice between making television shows (my largest audience ever was 25 million people, according to the ratings) and playing live music in a tavern, is that the people in the tavern listen to you and smile and clap and the people in the television audience just watch for an hour and change the channel over to Shark Week or something whatever. They don't call you up to let you know what they thought of your show. Once I was playing to an empty room by myself in the little local restaurant, when an older local lady, missing a front tooth, walked in carrying a can of Pabst Blue Ribbon beer and sat down in front of me. “Do you know any Conway Twitty?’ She asked. “No” I said “but I can do George Jones.” And so I did a few numbers and she smiled all the way through it. And I tell you what, that little exchange, was more satisfying than the great majority of work I ever did on television.

Expand full comment

Love that story.

Expand full comment

I love that, Robert.

Expand full comment

Do you have any of your bands music online Robert? Would love to hear.

Expand full comment

i hear ya 100% we are persons, meant to be personable. Thanks for sharing <3

Expand full comment

This may interest Stephen Sondheim aficionados and indie musicians. I'm just back from the GRAMMY Awards, where my album "To Steve With Love: Liz Callaway Celebrates Sondheim" was nominated for Best Traditional Pop Vocal Album. To be nominated in this mainstream category for a live album that I self-produced at the age of 62 was a huge surprise. Here is a link to where you can listen to the album, as well as a PDF of the 16-page booklet:

www.lizcallaway.com/grammy-fyc

I also started a Substack newsletter called "Between Flights"- it's a work in progress, but I'm keen to use my Substack as a way of sharing songs and behind-the-scenes of my work in a way that social media algorithms don't allow. You can check it out here:

https://lizcallaway.substack.com/

Thanks for the open mic day, Ted- I've learned a lot from you about the music business and Substack- that knowledge is invaluable as I plan what my next album may be.

Expand full comment

wow Liz! I am impressed, good for you. Life starts at 60.

Expand full comment

That’s amazing

Expand full comment

Congrats Liz ...fabulous outfits by the way!

Expand full comment

Hi! We fact-check and curate commentary from liberal and conservative media on one topic a day: https://www.theflipside.io/ Social media shows us the worst of both sides; we show you the best!

Expand full comment

I'm in!

Expand full comment

That’s brilliant. Would love to have this in The Netherlands

Expand full comment

"No clickbait. No trolls." I love it.

Expand full comment

Thanks for doing this, Ted!

My newsletter is for music fans that remember when music discovery was personal, and mixtapes were an artform.

I know there are a lot of jazz fans here, so if I may, I'd like to link to a really cool project being being built by a guy named Greg Layton. He is putting liner notes online in one spot--many of which would other wise be lost to the ages. Well worth your time to check out!

https://thejazztome.info/

Expand full comment

That sounds great - have you come across writing about Cassette tapes in places like Egypt? I have a book in my research backlog to read

This isn't the book but it's that direction: https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2023/8/30/sixty-years-of-sound-the-cassettes-past-present-and-future-in-egypt

Expand full comment

I haven’t, but thank you for the link!

Expand full comment

Thank you for doing this for all of us. I was born in 1979, slightly after the great jazz albums had been released, so for me it's a real gift to discover a lot of wonderful music.

Expand full comment

Love the thought of this. I still have (20+ year old) mix tapes made by friends back when painstakingly recording from a CD player was how you turned your friends onto what spark you feel.

Funny how I felt that streaming made me miss the concept of liner notes. While kvetching about this very thing to my high school aged nephew, he pointed out that artists now write extensive interpretations of their lyrics for genius.com, give copious interviews to innumerable youtube channels, and put everything out there. And he was right! And it felt like way too much. Like intense navel gazing.

So maybe I just miss the days of reading about Metallica's "Crew Fuckers 88/89" and painting a picture in my mind about how cool that must be. And, you know, you can't go back. Or maybe we've gone from a tantalizing drip of information to a deluge and the mystery is gone.

Expand full comment

Currently, I'm making the changes requested by my publisher for my biography of Cootie Williams. Hopefully, it will be published at the end of the year. Next month, the companion 4-CD set is being released with liner notes by yours truly. (It's already available in the UK.) The Duke Ellington Society of Sweden published a very nice write up on the set - https://ellingtongalaxy.org/2024/01/28/cootie-williams-selected-recordings-1928-1962/

Expand full comment

Firstly, I'm writing a very Ted-influenced Jewish musicology newsletter on Substack -- mattausterklein.substack.com.

Secondly, I'm thinking of starting a national archive for cantorial manuscripts. This is handwritten stuff from the 19th/20th century that Jewish cantors composed or wrote out for their own services, and which have been passed for generations between cantorial families or from master to student. If no one finds a home for these now (like Aaron Lansky did for Yiddish Books), they will end up in the garbage and a huge part of our music heritage will be lost.

I helped start a digital archive for a few major collections, but there's a ton more out there and still no physical home for these precious works of Jewish expressive culture. Who's with me?

Here's a long form of my pitch on Substack: https://open.substack.com/pub/mattausterklein/p/a-legacy-of-trust?r=9bb6s&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

Expand full comment

I clicked over to your substack. Top post is relating James Brown to the High Holydays? Insta-subscribe.

Expand full comment

That’s wonderful but I know how enormously hard it is. Don’t want to be too snarky, but I think summer camp tunes should stay where they belong, and (don’t hate on me) real music should have its place Fridays and Saturdays.

Expand full comment

Just subscribed to you 😎

Expand full comment

Thanks! I like congregational singing (philosophically and practically) but I don’t like it when the words are just secondary to the camp ethos. And I’m classically trained so the spirituality of musical complexity is in my bones. (You’re in Germany, so there’s a lot of that around, no?)

Expand full comment

I look forward to checking out your Substack and following your efforts. I have a love-hate relationship with cantorial music. Much of it is beautiful and it is of course an important part of our tradition, but it can also be stultifying for congregations. For me personally, it's more enjoyable in concert settings than in shul.

Expand full comment

Thanks, Jordan! I think a lot of the problem with “cantorial”/specialized synagogue music has to do with trust and psychology. Do I trust/believe in what the leader is doing? Is space also being made for my own voice? I tend to combine hazzanut with niggunim in order to have both expression and engagement. Thanks for following my substack and I welcome your comments.

Expand full comment

Cantorial music is so beautiful. Glad that you are doing this.

Expand full comment

It’s meaningful but there’s not a ton of funding lying around for this kinda stuff (Unless the right person reads this Substack!). I love the repertoire and the stories behind it.

Expand full comment

Thanks! I agree! I used to be more of a populist but now I go for the old stuff. This is the archive I helped start btw: archive.cantors.org

Expand full comment

Putting the finishing touches on Now You're One of Us, the story of the band Redd Kross — which I'm writing with band co-founders Jeff and Steven McDonald. Should be out this fall via Omnibus Press!

Expand full comment

This is extremely cool, I can’t wait to read this.

Expand full comment

Self promo time, baby! Doing whatever I feel like creatively, but basically a song a month and an occasional episode of TV, all on Substack: miter.substack.com

https://miter.substack.com/p/salon-du-monde-fremont-003

Expand full comment

I’m helping my best friend with her project helping Americans and other internationals who move to Denmark. www.howtoliveindenmark.com

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing this! I just checked out Kay's website and would love to feature her on my podcast. I'll reach out to her.

Expand full comment