Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Ehrlich's avatar

Eventually I will have so many paid substack subscriptions that the writers will get together and charge one flat fee for all their writing in one place and thereby reinvent the magazine.

Expand full comment
Tad La Fountain's avatar

I concur with the entirety of your observations. And I'd like to add another:

The New Yorker and The Atlantic are held up as survivors and paragons. But while I subscribe to both, I am flummoxed by their daily/newsletter offerings. I wish to support thoughtful and observant editorial content - which just doesn't happen when such material is microwaved and not lovingly (and leisurely) prepared. I have the New York Times, the Washington Post and the Philadelphia Inquirer to allegedly provide me with "news" - although they seem to be following each other down the "lifestyle" rabbit hole. What I crave is a curated menu of well-prepared entrees that I can mull over and roll over my intellectual tongue - savoring every morsel. Fat chance.

The world is awash in cleverness; I seek wisdom from people much smarter and more accomplished than myself, who can weave their thoughts into a tapestry of provocative (and well-supported) clarion calls to my noggin. Knee-jerk responses from Remnick, et al really don't pass muster.

Long-form journalism may have left the building (I can recall when The New Yorker regularly had articles that spanned two or three issues). But I'm afraid the headlong rush to "punchy" content has led to a punch-drunk audience. And the cycle will continue to keep on unabated until...well, I'm not sure what turns it around. But the debasement and decline of intellectual property in all of its guises is but a tocsin of the death of a society.

Expand full comment
179 more comments...

No posts