Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Larry.Deaton@gmail.com's avatar

Great article. One very off track comment, pursuant to this: "I was apprehensive when I heard this—I tend to dislike very loud music, and have even walked out of concerts for that reason." I like Mark Knopfler for his songs and his guitar playing, but I also admire him for what I read about when his band Dire Straits was getting started and people in small venues kept on telling the band to play louder. Knopfler woudn't let them ... consequently decades later, Knopfler still has his hearing while many rock musicians, even some much younger than him, don't.

Expand full comment
Tom Rhea's avatar

Wish I had a crystal singing bowl, have several metal ones.

Could it be that these bowls and similar instruments such as bells, have partials that are not always harmonic, and that adds to the interest and strangeness to Westerners? Orchestral instruments have primarily harmonic partials, and as such seem more cerebral, rational, and linear to me. (Don't get me wrong, I love symphonic music!)

Wish I could be there, or had heard La Monte Young's Just intonation experiences . . . one of the reasons "samples" don't work is not due to the sound itself, but the fact that most MIDI instruments that play them are stuck on the equi-tempered scale . . . "temperament" may be a lost art, and perhaps is of greater importance than we imagine nowadays.

Expand full comment
50 more comments...

No posts