Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dheep''s avatar

Sounds a bit like an actual Thread from a Guitar / Guitar Gear forum I read regularly. You gotta step very carefully there if you dare comment (having been kicked off before)

Expand full comment
Ferg's avatar

I liked Whiplash, but I also didn't have any preconceptions that it had to reflect exactly my personal experiences. So many people were like, "That's not what music school is like! This movie sucks."

Yeah, and Star Wars isn't what it's like to be an astronaut. We're talking fiction, not documentaries.

Yet here come the Jazz Police to tell me that it sucked because it was nothing like their specific experience at their specific school. Whatever. That's not the point.

The movie isn't even about "being in music school" or "being a drummer". To me, it's a tale of an abusive person in power, and asks the question to what extent is it acceptable to push people into areas where they are uncomfortable? Also, what drives the person who is being abused to keep accepting such abuse? The film asks a bunch of other mentor/student questions as well, the drumming and the music school is just the setting.

As someone who absolutely endured several years of *very* abusive teachers (as a young child where there was no opting out) I can say with 100% certainty that while Whiplash didn't look like what *you* went through in your music school experience, there are many folks for whom the central premise--abuse of power, specifically bullying by a teacher--resonated strongly.

Expand full comment
56 more comments...

No posts