Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dom Aversano's avatar

This is an excellent read, thanks Ted. I appreciate the honesty which was constructive and didn’t seem negative to me.

One thing I sense is since the means of production have changed for music, as well as how it is delivered, the whole concept of a ‘recording industry’ is perhaps a questionable frame to view music. Selling recordings made sense in the previous technological era, where music was scarce, but now it is ubiquitous one has to think differently.

If I was working at a major label I’d be looking to the gaming industry to learn. I don’t mean that music should, or will, be gamified, but that is an industry that has learned to sell software. Vinyl’s cool, and I expect it will still be sold 60 years from now, but it’s a side salad, the real meal is software. I don’t think musicians have wrapped their heads around this for the most part, and I doubt the recording industry is really capable yet. Ninja Tune had a go at it, but were perhaps too early, and too far ahead.

Music may be created that is not a song, not a fixed composition, and evolves in a non-linear way. A bit like a lot of music before the recording industry. It will work like software, and therefore it’s essential representation will be the algorithm, not a fixed output, or recording. This, I expect, will be easier to sell and make a living from than fixed recordings, which possibly have had their golden era. I would have more faith in a upstart to create this than a lumbering giant from a bygone era. In fact, musically, this is exactly what I’m working on right now.

Expand full comment
Fitness's avatar

From Wikipedia, about this "vital and happening indie music business":

On August 4, 2017, the staff of Bandcamp Daily donated all of the day's sales proceeds to the Transgender Law Center, a civil rights organization for transgender people.[47]

In response to the protests that took place following the murder of George Floyd and other African Americans who had died from police violence, Bandcamp announced that for 24 hours on June 19, 2020 they would donate 100% of profits to the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.[31]

Sounds like it was already firmly part of the same corporate ecosystem as everything else and not particularly independent.

Expand full comment
71 more comments...

No posts