Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carolyn Zeytoonian's avatar

Ted, this is such an excellent essay that I had to share it in several places!

My favorite quote:

"If you shoot hoops at the gym, no one cares, but if you play in the NBA Finals, a million people criticize your every move. And it’s just as true in everyday work environments—the more responsibility you take on, the more you will be scrutinized and found wanting. So at least comfort yourself with the realization that tough and even unwarranted criticism is typically a sign that you’ve made some genuine progress." -- Ted Gioia

Expand full comment
Tom Greenland's avatar

As a fellow critic, I can relate. My big issue is how critical can you be? I feel like the bias, for various reasons, is towards positivity. Personally, I'm always looking for the interesting parts of the music, not so much whether I "like" it or not. I don't think it really matters if I like it or not, as along as the music stands on its own feet on its own terms.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts